Let’s Stop Gendering Graduation Ceremonies

The boys in my graduating class of 1992 hated their grey graduation gowns; they joked that they looked like baked potatoes.  Meanwhile, the girls wore striking red gowns.  Our school colors were reflected in the sea of red and grey on the floor of the gymnasium.

The optics of these two colors could move one to pride, to relief that one made it through high school, or maybe to fear of what is coming next.  But also these optics, which can be satisfying visually, have a problem at their core:  they support the idea that gender is a binary—girls/boys—and do not create any space for our now better understanding of gender and its fluidity.  The tradition of having two colors of gowns should be reconsidered in school communities in order to support non-binary students, transgender students, and any other students who do not see themselves reflected in a binary system of gender.

Elizabeth Meyer, Associate Dean of Students and Associate Professor of Educational Foundations, Policy, and Practice at the School of Education at the University of Colorado, Boulder, talks about the many instances in which school traditions rely on outdated ideas about gender including yearbook photos, proms, and commencement.  She argues,

In the face of these potential harms, the ethical school leader should find a way to ensure that school is a safe and supportive place for students of all gender identities and expressions. Schools can work individually to ensure transgender and non-binary students have options they feel are affirming of their identity, or they can work more systemically to create rituals that are more inclusive and universally supportive of the diversity in their student body. 

When celebrating commencement, all students should be able to celebrate themselves and their accomplishments.  For students who do not find their identities within a gender binary, commencement forces them to visibly participate in gender norms that deny their existence. Jey Ehrenhalt writes about the need for transgender and non-binary students to be seen, to have their existences recognized, “Transgender youth are looking, first and foremost, for adults to respect their chosen names and pronouns. Making this effort validates young people’s core identity and solidifies their safety.”  Forcing a student to choose (or perhaps even being forced into) a gown gendered by color means the school does not validate the student’s “core identity” at the critical moment when that school is launching that young adult out into the world. Even if every other moment during the school experience was validating and inclusive, the final moment when a student walks across the stage—if forced into a certain color gown—can undo much of the good work done by teachers, administrators, and classmates.

The decision to change the gowns to one color (which most higher education institutions do) can be unpopular. Recently the West Chester School District in Pennsylvania announced they would use one color of gown starting in 2020.  While much of the community had a positive reaction to a decision that Superintendent Jim Scanlon says “we should have done this 25 years ago,” some members of the community accuse the district of tarnishing traditions.

And that person is right: those traditions are being tarnished. Because they need to be.  Holding on to a tradition that invalidates the existences of a population of students is not worth the optics.  These graduation ceremonies will look different. But that difference is not bad—that difference in optics signifies the community wants to celebrate all of the students that day in a way that supports each student.  That difference signifies that the community has evolved and learned right along with its students and knows that a student’s life being validated is more important than a tradition.

Image result for commons graduation

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Postcolonial Literature in the Modern World

Thoughtful Discussions and Insights Regarding Postcolonial Literature, Diverse Cultures, and the Broad Spectrum of the Human Condition

Esperando por una Revolución

Una Historia de Amor


Women & Pregnancy

Exploring the experiences women have during pregnancy

DemiConsensual: Gender, Sexuality, and Feminism in the Modern World

Making sense of all things gender, sexuality, identity, and feminist in our current culture.

The Female Reflection

A blog of opinon based responses to female literature & film

Standardized Testing

How testing harms children

Lay's Thoughts

Feminist Theory

TEACHING FEMINISM

A blog about how to navigate feminism

Reflections for Educators

A website for using the Reflections series in the classroom

Small Town Feminist

Thoughts and comments from a college feminist living in a small town.

2016 Presidential Election: Women's and Gender Issues

"Gender equality is more than a goal in itself. It is a precondition for meeting the challenge of reducing poverty, promoting sustainable development and building good governance." — Kofi Annan

Rise Up Doylestown!

We stand together in solidarity with our partners and children for the protection of our rights, our safety, our health, and our families - recognizing that our vibrant and diverse communities are the strength of our country.

KU Postcolonial Theory and Texts

“Create dangerously, for people who read dangerously. ... Writing, knowing in part that no matter how trivial your words may seem, someday, somewhere, someone may risk his or her life to read them.” Edwidge Danticat

%d bloggers like this: